If you've been tracking the standardized testing conversation—and if you're applying to selective colleges, you should be—you know that the landscape has shifted dramatically in the past year. This guide is part of our broader coverage of standardized testing strategy, and the timing matters: more than half the Ivy League now requires test scores, reversing pandemic-era policies that many assumed were permanent.
The Testing Pendulum Swings Back
Here's the bottom line: while more than 80% of U.S. four-year institutions remain test-optional or test-free according to FairTest, the schools most applicants are obsessing over have largely abandoned that approach. Harvard, Yale, Brown, and Dartmouth all reinstated requirements effective for Fall 2025 entry, with announcements rolling out in early-to-mid 2024. This isn't a subtle trend—it's a coordinated recalibration by elite institutions.
The justifications these schools offered are worth noting. Dartmouth and Harvard both cited internal research showing that test scores actually help identify talented students from under-resourced high schools—students whose GPAs might not reflect their potential because of limited course offerings or grade inflation elsewhere. A 2025 NBER study reinforced this, finding that disadvantaged students with SAT scores above 1400 increase their admission probability by 3.6 times when they submit scores. First-generation applicants raise their chances by 2.4 times.
I find this framing interesting. For years, the narrative positioned standardized testing as an equity barrier. Now the research suggests that for high-achieving students from lower-income backgrounds, opting out of score submission may actually hurt them.
Ivy League Testing Requirements
The Ivy League is now split, with the majority requiring tests and a shrinking minority holding onto test-optional policies. Here's exactly where each school stands:
| University | Testing Policy | Effective Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Harvard | Required | Fall 2025 entry | Announced 2024 |
| Yale | Required | Fall 2025 entry | SAT or ACT now required; AP/IB scores optional extras |
| Brown | Required | Fall 2025 entry | Exception for documented access issues |
| Dartmouth | Required | Fall 2025 entry | First Ivy to reinstate (Feb 2024) |
| Penn | Required | Fall 2026 entry | Test-optional for Fall 2025 applicants |
| Cornell | Required | Fall 2026 entry | SAT or ACT required for first-year applicants |
| Columbia | Test-Optional | Required from 2027-2028 cycle | Open-ended test-optional policy ended; waivers available |
| Princeton | Test-Optional | Required from 2027-28 cycle | Return to testing announced Oct. 2025 |
Yale's policy deserves attention. Applicants must submit either the SAT or the ACT; AP or IB scores are optional and may be included alongside an SAT or ACT score. For more context on Yale's specific policy changes, we've covered the details elsewhere.
Elite Non-Ivies: A Similar Pattern
The reinstatement trend extends well beyond the Ivy League. MIT led the way back in March 2022, and a cascade of announcements has followed. Stanford, notably, is reinstating requirements for the 2025-2026 application cycle (Fall 2026 entry), while Caltech moved from test-free to test-required for Fall 2025.
| University | Status | Effective Date |
|---|---|---|
| MIT | Required | Since March 2022 |
| Caltech | Required | Fall 2025 entry |
| Stanford | Required | Fall 2026 entry |
| Georgetown | Required | Ongoing |
| Johns Hopkins | Required | Fall 2026 entry |
| Carnegie Mellon SCS | Required | Fall 2026 entry |
| UT Austin | Required | Fall 2025 entry |
Public universities in Georgia and Florida also require scores, though not uniformly. For Fall 2026 and later, the University System of Georgia requires SAT or ACT scores at UGA, Georgia Tech, Georgia State, Augusta University, Kennesaw State, Georgia Southern and Georgia College & State University; other USG institutions may require them depending on an applicant's high school GPA. The University of Florida requires test scores and never stopped requiring them; Florida's public universities kept the testing requirement throughout the pandemic, so UF did not need to reinstate it.
What Scores Actually Matter
Competitive scores for Ivy League admission sit at 1500+ on the SAT and 33-35 on the ACT. For context, the national average SAT score was 1024 in 2024. That's a significant gap, and it underscores why test preparation remains a serious investment for students targeting these schools.
During test-optional cycles, approximately 40-55% of Ivy League applicants still chose to submit scores. This self-selection created an interesting dynamic: students who submitted tended to have strong scores, which meant not submitting became a signal in itself. Admissions officers understood what a missing score line often meant.
If you're weighing whether your scores strengthen your application, the decision framework for test-optional submissions walks through the calculus in detail.
Timeline Considerations
Application deadlines haven't changed alongside these policy shifts. Ivy League Early Decision deadlines cluster around November 1-15, which means the October SAT of senior year is typically the last viable test date for early applicants. Regular Decision deadlines fall between January 1-7.
Score reports cost $12 each after your initial four free reports (included when you register or within nine days of testing). Rush delivery runs $31 for 2-4 business day processing, though most schools don't require official scores until after admission.
The Strategic Reality
The schools that remain test-optional—including 28 of the top 50 liberal arts colleges and institutions like NYU through 2026-2027—still represent excellent options for students who prefer to apply without scores. Columbia, once the Ivy with no end date on its policy, will require SAT or ACT scores starting with the 2027-2028 cycle. But the list of highly selective schools where testing isn't optional is growing, not shrinking.
My take: if your target list includes any of the schools reinstating requirements, treat test preparation as non-negotiable. The broader shifts in testing policy suggest this isn't a temporary correction but a genuine reassessment of what standardized tests contribute to admissions decisions. Schools aren't requiring scores because they want to make admissions harder—they're doing it because their data suggests scores help them build stronger, more diverse classes.
Whether you find that reasoning persuasive is beside the point. The policy is the policy, and your application strategy needs to account for it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Columbia and Princeton remain test-optional for now, but both have announced a return to required testing: Princeton beginning with the 2027-28 admission cycle, and Columbia with the 2027-2028 cycle (with waivers available). Every other Ivy League school either requires tests now or will require them starting with Fall 2026 entry.
Competitive scores sit at 1500 or above on the SAT (out of 1600) and 33-35 on the ACT. The national average SAT score was 1024 in 2024, so admitted Ivy League students typically score roughly 500 points above the mean.
Generally, submit if your scores fall within or above the middle 50% range for admitted students. NBER research shows that high-achieving students from disadvantaged backgrounds significantly improve their admission odds by submitting strong scores.
The October SAT of your senior year is typically the last viable test date for Early Decision applications, given that most Ivy League ED deadlines fall around November 1-15. Plan accordingly and build in retake opportunities during junior year.
Schools cite research showing that test scores help identify talented students from under-resourced high schools and predict college success. The argument has shifted from 'tests are barriers' to 'tests can reveal potential that grades alone might miss.'
