If you've been following the broader standardized testing landscape, you've probably noticed that the narrative around SAT and ACT requirements has become almost impossible to pin down. One week, you hear that test-optional is permanent. The next, an Ivy League school announces it's bringing scores back. The truth is that college testing policy isn't moving in one direction—it's fracturing into two distinct tracks, and understanding which track your target schools are on matters enormously for your planning.
The Numbers Reveal a Genuinely Divided Landscape
Here's the bottom line: more than 2,000 four-year institutions remain test-optional for the 2025-2026 cycle, with an additional 85 schools maintaining fully test-free policies, according to FairTest. That's the overwhelming majority of American higher education. And yet, over half the Ivy League now requires test scores for incoming classes. Both of these facts are true simultaneously, which is why simple advice about testing strategy falls flat.
The test-optional movement didn't emerge from the pandemic, though COVID certainly accelerated it. Bowdoin College went test-optional in 1970. What the pandemic did was create a natural experiment at scale—suddenly, thousands of institutions could observe what happened when testing became truly optional, and many discovered they preferred the results. The University of California system made its test-blind policy permanent in 2021-2022 and shows no signs of reversing course.
But while the mass of American colleges moved in one direction, something different started happening at the most selective institutions. The data they collected during the test-optional years apparently told them a different story. For a complete breakdown of which schools still don't require scores, the list remains extensive—but it's the exceptions that demand attention.
Elite Schools Are Reinstating Requirements on a Rolling Basis
The return to testing requirements at highly selective schools isn't a single wave—it's a staggered rollout that continues to expand. Harvard, Brown, and Dartmouth all reinstated requirements for Fall 2025 admission, affecting the Class of 2029. Yale adopted a test-flexible policy for that class and now requires ACT or SAT scores starting with the 2026-2027 application cycle. Cornell followed: starting with fall 2026 enrollment, first-year applicants to all eight of its undergraduate colleges must submit SAT or ACT scores. And in 2025, additional announcements from the University of Pennsylvania, Johns Hopkins, Ohio State, and the University of Miami pushed the requirement forward to their Fall 2026 admission cycles.
| Institution | Policy Change | Effective Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Harvard University | Reinstated requirement | Fall 2025 (Class of 2029) | SAT or ACT required |
| Yale University | Reinstated requirement | 2026-2027 application cycle | SAT or ACT required; AP/IB no longer accepted |
| Brown University | Reinstated requirement | Fall 2025 (Class of 2029) | SAT or ACT required |
| Dartmouth College | Reinstated requirement | Fall 2025 (Class of 2029) | International students may use AP/IB |
| Cornell University | Reinstated requirement | Fall 2026 (Class of 2030) | Varies by college for Fall 2025 |
| University of Pennsylvania | Reinstated requirement | Fall 2026 admission | Announced early 2025 |
| Johns Hopkins University | Reinstated requirement | Fall 2026 admission | Announced August 2024 |
| MIT | Never dropped requirement | Ongoing | Always required scores |
| Georgetown University | Never dropped requirement | Ongoing | Always required scores |
Yale's approach has shifted. It first adopted a "test-flexible" policy that accepted AP or IB exam scores as alternatives, but it has since dropped that option: all first-year and transfer applicants must now include scores from the ACT or SAT. For the full context on Yale's specific policy changes, the details matter for applicants considering that school.
MIT and Georgetown, notably, never wavered. They maintained testing requirements throughout the pandemic and beyond, making them outliers during the test-optional surge but perhaps early indicators of where elite admissions was heading.
State Policies Create Additional Complexity
State-level policies add another layer to navigate, and they're genuinely all over the map. California's UC and CSU systems are permanently test-blind—they won't consider your scores even if you submit them. Florida's public universities went the opposite direction and reinstated requirements. Georgia presents perhaps the most confusing picture: the University System of Georgia's temporary test-optional waiver covered 22 of its 25 institutions for Academic Year 2025-2026 only, and Georgia Tech, the University of Georgia, and Georgia College and State University were explicitly excluded from it. That waiver has ended: for admission for Fall 2026 and later, SAT or ACT scores are required at UGA, Georgia Tech, Georgia State, Augusta, Kennesaw State, Georgia Southern, and Georgia College & State University.
Washington and Colorado have maintained test-optional policies for their public universities. The practical effect is that students applying broadly—especially across state lines—may face a patchwork of requirements that demands careful tracking.
Strategic Implications for Students Planning Ahead
If you're targeting highly selective institutions, the strategic calculus has shifted. You should probably prepare for and take the SAT or ACT, regardless of whether a specific school technically requires it. At schools where testing is optional but most admitted students submit scores, not having a score to report puts you at an informational disadvantage—admissions officers are working with less evidence of your academic preparation.
The practical details matter here. The SAT is offered eight times during the 2025-2026 testing year: August, September, October, November, and December 2026, plus March, May, and June 2027. Registration costs $68, with a $38 late registration fee if you miss the regular deadline. For eligible low-income 11th and 12th graders, fee waivers cover two free SAT tests and unlimited score reports—a substantial benefit worth pursuing through your school counselor.
For students with genuinely strong applications but test scores that don't match their academic record, the remaining test-optional schools provide real options. Duke, Boston University, and the University of Alabama all maintain test-optional policies through at least Fall 2026. The question of whether to submit scores to test-optional schools requires honest assessment of where your scores fall relative to admitted student profiles.
The institutions reinstating requirements have generally framed the decision around equity—arguing that test scores actually help them identify promising students from under-resourced high schools who might otherwise lack the extracurriculars and course offerings that more privileged students can demonstrate. Whether this argument holds up in practice remains to be seen. What's clear is that the admissions landscape isn't returning to a single standard anytime soon. The two-track reality is here, and your strategy needs to account for it.
