If you're in the process of building your college list, you've probably noticed that the conversation around elite universities has shifted considerably. The traditional Ivy League still commands attention, but a growing cohort of institutions now competes directly for top students and employer respect. These are the New Ivies, and understanding them is essential for anyone serious about identifying schools that combine academic rigor with genuine career outcomes.
What Exactly Are the New Ivies?
The New Ivies are institutions that match or exceed traditional Ivy League schools in selectivity, academic quality, and employer perception, without the centuries-old branding. Forbes popularized the term and releases an annual list based on specific criteria: schools must have substantial enrollment, use standardized test scores in admissions, and demonstrate strong employer preference.
The concept overlaps with but differs from other elite groupings. The Ivy Plus schools (Stanford, MIT, Duke, University of Chicago) are explicitly excluded from Forbes' New Ivies list, as are the actual Ivy League institutions. Similarly, Public Ivies and Hidden Ivies represent related but distinct categories worth exploring as you research.
Forbes' methodology requires private schools to have at least 3,500 students and public schools to have 4,000 or more. This minimum threshold eliminates smaller liberal arts colleges regardless of their prestige. The requirement that schools use standardized test scores in admissions knocked out the entire University of California system, which no longer reports SAT or ACT data.
The 2025 Forbes New Ivies List
Forbes released an updated list for 2025 featuring 20 institutions split evenly between public and private schools. Six newcomers joined this year: West Point, William & Mary, Tufts University, Washington University in St. Louis, Purdue University, and the University of Pittsburgh. Meanwhile, the University of Florida and Binghamton University were removed from the previous year's list.
William & Mary, founded in 1693, earned particular distinction as the most "Ivy-like" among the public New Ivies according to Forbes. As the second-oldest college in the United States, it brings genuine historical pedigree to the conversation. Applications reached 17,799 in 2024, representing a 25% increase since 2020.
Here's what the selectivity looks like across notable New Ivies for the 2024-2025 admissions cycle:
| Institution | Acceptance Rate | Type | Notable Detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notre Dame | 9% | Private | Historic low, down from 11.1% previous year |
| West Point | 10% | Public (Federal) | Tuition-free with service commitment |
| Washington University in St. Louis | 13% | Private | 27,900 applicants in 2024 |
| University of Michigan | 17% (12% out-of-state) | Public | Median SAT 1475 |
The private New Ivies collectively have a median SAT score of 1530 and acceptance rates as low as one in seven applicants. These numbers put them squarely in competition with several Ivy League schools, where Harvard and Caltech now sit at 3% acceptance rates.
The Employer Sentiment Shift
What's driving the New Ivies phenomenon isn't just selectivity metrics but a meaningful change in how employers view elite credentials. Forbes surveyed over 380 C-suite executives, and the results should concern anyone banking solely on Ivy League prestige. A full 37% of executives reported being less likely to hire Ivy League graduates compared to five years ago.
Even more striking: 40% of respondents said Ivy League schools are now doing a worse job preparing entry-level candidates for the workforce. Employers increasingly prioritize practical skills, demonstrated workforce readiness, and diverse experiences over traditional brand names. The New Ivies have positioned themselves to capitalize on this shift by emphasizing career outcomes, internship partnerships, and return on investment.
This doesn't mean Ivy League degrees have become worthless, obviously. But it does suggest that the automatic premium once attached to Harvard or Yale has eroded. For students weighing elite options, the New Ivies now represent genuinely competitive alternatives rather than consolation prizes.
Notre Dame as a Case Study
Notre Dame's Class of 2029 admissions cycle illustrates the competitive intensity of New Ivies. The university received 35,401 applications, an 18% increase year-over-year, and admitted roughly 3,200 students for a 9% overall acceptance rate. This marks the first time Notre Dame's acceptance rate dipped below 10%, putting it in the same selectivity bracket as several Ivy League institutions.
The breakdown by application round is worth noting:
| Application Round | Acceptance Rate | Applicants | Admitted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Early Action | 12.9% | 12,917 | 1,669 |
| Regular Decision | 6.7% | ~22,500 | ~1,500 |
| Overall | 9% | 35,401 | ~3,200 |
Notre Dame's yield rate hit 62% for the Class of 2028, the highest in university history. The national average is around 30%. When students get into Notre Dame, they go. That's a powerful signal about genuine student preference, not just applicant volume.
Admitted students' SAT scores range from 1470 to 1540, with ACT scores between 33 and 35. The university remains test-optional through the 2025-26 cycle, though test-optional policies across elite schools have contributed to application surges everywhere. Students now apply to an average of 6.1 institutions, and early decision applications have reached record highs.
Financial Realities
New Ivies aren't cheap, but several offer substantial financial aid. Notre Dame's 2024-2025 tuition runs $67,100, with room and board adding another $18,438. However, the university meets 100% of demonstrated financial need, and the average financial aid package for first-year students with need is $67,855, essentially covering full tuition.
West Point represents a unique value proposition: tuition is entirely free in exchange for a five-year active duty commitment followed by three years in the reserves. With a 10% acceptance rate, it's as selective as most elite private institutions but removes the financial burden entirely for students willing to serve.
The financial calculus matters because New Ivies often deliver comparable career outcomes at lower net costs than some traditional Ivy League schools. When employers are increasingly indifferent to which elite school you attended, the debt-to-outcome ratio becomes more relevant than raw prestige.
