Alia
How It WorksPlansAbout Us
Log In
  1. Library
  2. /Application Strategy & Timeline
  3. /

What Two Years Without Affirmative Action Reveals

Application Strategy & Timeline · Admissions Policy Changes

  1. Library
  2. /Application Strategy & Timeline
  3. /What Two Years Without Affirmative Action Reveals

If you're navigating college admissions strategy today, understanding how the landscape has shifted since the Supreme Court ended race-based affirmative action is essential context. Two years of data are now available, and the picture is complicated—significant declines at some schools, surprising stability at others, and a legal environment that remains contentious. Here's what we actually know, and what it means for how you approach your applications.

The Data Is In, and It's Mixed

The numbers tell a story of uneven impact: overall diversity declined at schools that previously considered race, but the damage was concentrated at the most selective institutions while some elite schools held steady or improved. A CBS News analysis of 116 colleges found underrepresented minority enrollment dropped by roughly 2 percentage points at the 76 schools that had used race-conscious admissions. At the 17 most selective schools—those accepting fewer than 10% of applicants—minority enrollment fell nearly 5 percentage points.

Black student representation took the hardest hit. Across schools that previously considered race, Black enrollment dropped from 6.4% to 5.3%, the lowest level since at least 2015. The declines at specific institutions were even more dramatic:

InstitutionBlack Enrollment BeforeBlack Enrollment AfterChange
MIT15%5%-10 percentage points
UNC Chapel Hill10.5%7.8%-2.7 percentage points
11 most competitive Massachusetts schools (average)Baseline-40% from two-year averageSevere decline

But here's where it gets interesting: Yale, Princeton, Duke, and the University of Virginia maintained or slightly increased their diversity numbers. These aren't outliers—they're institutions that invested heavily in alternative strategies before and immediately after the ruling. The divergence in outcomes suggests that institutional commitment and resources matter as much as the legal constraints themselves.

The Legal Landscape Keeps Shifting

If you thought the June 2023 ruling settled things, you haven't been paying attention. Students for Fair Admissions—the organization that brought the original cases—sent letters to Yale, Princeton, and Duke demanding they explain how they maintained diversity and threatening litigation if the answers suggest indirect race consideration. The implication is clear: success in maintaining diversity now invites legal scrutiny.

Meanwhile, in March 2025 the Department of Education opened investigations into 45 universities over their partnerships with The Ph.D. Project. It has since secured resolution agreements with 31 of them, under which they end those partnerships. A lawsuit filed against the University of California system in March 2025 claims the UC schools are indirectly considering race by prioritizing applicants from predominantly minority-serving high schools—even though California banned race-based preferences back in 1996. And across the country, 135 anti-DEI bills have been introduced in 29 states since 2023, with 29 signed into law by June 2025.

The legal battles extend beyond admissions to questions about legacy preferences that some argue constitute their own form of affirmative action. The irony isn't lost on observers that race-conscious policies face extinction while preferences for children of donors and alumni remain largely untouched at many institutions—though California's recent ban on legacy admissions suggests this may be changing.

What Schools Are Actually Doing

The most effective institutional responses share common elements: aggressive financial aid for low-income students, enhanced recruitment from diverse high schools, and holistic essay prompts that let students discuss how race has shaped their experiences. Chief Justice Roberts's majority opinion explicitly noted that students can still discuss how race affected their lives through discrimination or inspiration, and schools have leaned into this opening.

Duke announced an ambitious financial aid program for low-income students from the Carolinas just weeks before the ruling. UVA followed with its own initiative for Virginia residents in December 2023. Several highly selective schools—Brown, Yale, and Dartmouth among them—now require standardized test scores (Yale, for example, now requires all first-year and transfer applicants to submit either the SAT or the ACT), arguing that test scores help identify high-achieving students from disadvantaged backgrounds who might otherwise be overlooked.

The schools maintaining diversity appear to be working harder, spending more, and thinking more creatively about recruitment. Whether that model is sustainable—and whether it can be replicated at institutions with fewer resources—remains an open question.

What This Means for Your Strategy

For current applicants, the practical implications are significant. First, essay prompts matter more than ever. Many schools now include questions specifically designed to let you share how your background, including your racial identity, has shaped your perspective and experiences. Use them thoughtfully—the Court said you can discuss race in the context of your individual story; you just can't be evaluated as a representative of a racial category.

Second, understand that schools are evaluating diversity through proxies: socioeconomic status, first-generation status, geographic diversity, and the characteristics of your high school. If these factors are part of your story, make sure they come through in your application. The broader shifts in admissions policy make contextualizing your achievements within your environment more important than before.

Third, recognize that the schools most aggressively pursuing alternative diversity strategies are often the same ones being threatened with litigation. This creates uncertainty, but it also signals institutional commitment. When researching schools, look for evidence of concrete programs—financial aid initiatives, recruitment partnerships, support services—rather than just diversity statements.

Finally, there's a data collection problem that affects how we interpret everything. Increasing numbers of students are declining to report their race on applications, making year-over-year comparisons unreliable. Comprehensive applicant pool data won't be available until the 2025-26 federal data collection cycle. The FAFSA delays that affected fall 2024 enrollment add another confounding variable. We're seeing real trends, but the complete picture won't emerge for years.

The end of race-conscious admissions has reshaped the landscape, but it hasn't eliminated schools' interest in building diverse classes. The rules have changed; the underlying institutional goals, for most selective schools, have not. Your job as an applicant is to understand both.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. The Supreme Court explicitly stated that students can discuss how race has affected their lives through experiences of discrimination, sources of inspiration, or other personal contexts. Schools have added essay prompts specifically to create this opportunity. What's prohibited is using race as a categorical factor in evaluation—your individual experience remains fair game.

Most selective institutions have publicly committed to diversity and are pursuing it through race-neutral means: enhanced financial aid, socioeconomic considerations, recruitment from underrepresented high schools, and holistic review of personal circumstances. Some schools have maintained diversity numbers while others have seen significant declines—institutional strategy and resources appear to make a meaningful difference.

The ruling didn't directly address legacy preferences, but it intensified scrutiny of them. Critics argue that preferences for children of alumni constitute their own form of affirmative action that disproportionately benefits white applicants. California has already banned legacy admissions at private universities, and legal challenges are mounting elsewhere.

Schools like Yale, Princeton, Duke, and UVA invested heavily in alternative strategies—aggressive financial aid programs, enhanced recruitment, and socioeconomic considerations—before and immediately after the ruling. MIT, which saw Black enrollment drop from 15% to 5%, appears to have been more affected. The difference seems to come down to institutional preparation, resources, and strategic priorities.

Almost certainly. Students for Fair Admissions has threatened litigation against schools that maintained diversity. The Department of Education opened investigations into 45 universities over their Ph.D. Project partnerships and has since reached resolution agreements with 31 of them. Lawsuits challenging indirect race consideration are pending against the UC system. The legal landscape will likely remain contested for years, with outcomes depending on court interpretations of what constitutes permissible race-neutral practices.

More from this topic

Post-Affirmative Action Admissions Data Reveals Sharp Declines

California Bans Legacy Admissions But Stanford Opts Out

Legacy Admissions Under Attack After Supreme Court Ruling

Book a call with one of our experts

Get Started

Alia

  • How It Works
  • Eve
  • Roadmap
  • Plans
  • About Us
  • Contact

Resources

  • Library
  • Test Prep
  • Partnerships
  • Newsletter

Company

  • Careers
  • Security

Legal

  • Terms
  • Privacy

© 2026 Alia Education. All rights reserved.

XInstagramYouTubeLinkedIn